| 2007 All-WNY | |||
| First Team | |||
| G | Erinne Cuningham | 10 | Jamestown |
| G | Kacie Mills | 12 | Kenmore East |
| F | Kendra Brim | 12 | Nardin |
| F | Sarah Soroka | 12 | East Aurora |
| C | Joelle Connelly | 11 | Pioneer |
| Second Team | |||
| F | Bridgette Burke | 12 | Lockport |
| G | Nikki Frederickson | 11 | Jamestown |
| F | Brandy Wangelin | 12 | Olean |
| C | Ashley Dupler | 12 | Jamestown |
| G | Destiny Harrison | 12 | Niagara Falls |
| Third Team | |||
| C | Sam Kopp | 10 | Franklinville |
| G | Shakeena Cunningham | 12 | McKinley |
| G | Sierra Finch | 12 | Randolph |
| G | Barb Kiliszek | 12 | Lancaster |
| G | Marybeth Nugent | 12 | Springville |
| Fourth Team | |||
| C | Courtney Donovan | 12 | Grand Island |
| G | Katie Medina | 11 | Hamburg |
| G | Jessie Tarantino | 11 | East Aurora |
| G | Kaitlin Donahoe | 10 | Nichols |
| G | Jordan Schrimmel | 12 | Depew |