ALL-WNY 1st TEAM HISTORY
| 2008 | Joelle Connelly*** | Pioneer | Hofstra |
| Nikki Frederickson | Jamestown | undecided | |
| Erinne Cunningham | Jamestown | Jr | |
| Kaitlin Donahoe | Nichols | ||
| Sam Eimers | Ripley |
| 2007 | Joelle Connelly*** | Pioneer | Jr |
| Erinne Cunningham | Jamestown | Soph | |
| Kacie Mills | Kenmore East | Medaille | |
| Kendra Brim | Nardin | Colgate | |
| Sarah Soroka | East Aurora | Daemen | |
| 2006 | Elyse Monte*** | Sacred Heart | John Carroll |
| Colleen Quinn | Immaculata | Mercyhurst | |
| Kendra Brim | Nardin | Jr | |
| Joelle Connelly | Pioneer | Soph | |
| Sarah Houseknecht | Portville | Southern Conn. State U | |
| 2005 | Kelly Regan*** | Nichols | Manhattan College |
| Mary Kate Wilson | Mount Mercy | NYU/Daemen | |
| Megan McGuire | Grand Island | Carnege Mellon | |
| Kelly Haslinger | Nardin | SUNY Binghamton/ Soccer | |
| Carissa Ferrucci | Immaculata | Medaille | |
| 2004 | Heather Turner*** | Mount Mercy | SUNY Buffalo |
| Jamie Wolff | Nardin | St Lawrence | |
| Shannon Scarselletta | Nichols | Jr | |
| Mary Kate Wilson | Mount Mercy | Jr | |
| Kourtney Troutman | Pine Valley | Elmira College | |
| 2003 | Jill Ratchuk*** | Mount Mercy | Gannon/Mercyhst/Fredonia |
| Rachel Michalek | Sacred Heart | Sienna | |
| Andrea Muszynski | Mount Mercy | St Lawrence | |
| Jamie Wolff | Nardin | Jr | |
| Germany Jackson | Traditional | Daemen | |
| 2002 | Allison Depp*** | Lockport | Daemen |
| Tiffany Walton | Nichols | Niagara | |
| Rachel Michalek | Sacred Heart | Sienna | |
| Jill Ratchuk | Mount Mercy | Jr | |
| Rachel Pitkin | Kenmore East | SUNY Geneseo | |
| 2001 | Jamie Donnelly*** | Holy Angels | Iona |
| Allison Depp | Lockport | Jr | |
| Lindsay Brent | Williamsville East | West Point | |
| Eva Cunningham | Iroquois | Niagara | |
| Maria Atti | Kenmore East | William Smith | |
| 2000 | Jen Feher | Depew | LeMoyne |
| Katie MacFarlane | Clarence | West Point | |
| Adrienne Roseti | Williamsville East | Annapolis | |
| Eva Cunningham | Iroquois | Jr | |
| Katie Paradise | East Aurora | West Point | |
| 1999 | Lindsey Brent | Williamsville East | Soph |
| Jen Feher *** | Depew | Jr | |
| Katie MacFarlane | Clarence | Jr | |
| Adrienne Roseti | Williamsville East | Jr | |
| Angela Tylec | Niagara-Wheatfield | Kent State/ | |
| 1998 | Dana Fitchlee | Holy Angels | Niagara |
| Meghan House | Lewiston-Porter | ||
| Katie Laettner | Lake Shore | Wingate | |
| Nikki Smith | Pine Valley | Gannon | |
| Angela Tylec | Niagara-Wheatfield | Jr | |
| 1997 | Dana Fitchlee | Holy Angels | Jr |
| Meghan House | Lewiston-Porter | Jr | |
| Anna Parker | Fredonia | Lake Superior State | |
| Nikki Smith | Pine Valley | Jr | |
| Angela Tylec | Niagara-Wheatfield | Soph | |
| 1996 | Nicole Georgi | Lake Shore | |
| Sherry Laettner | Holy Angels | Daemen | |
| Tori Seibert | Sweet Home | No Carolina (Volleyball) | |
| Geraldine White | Lockport | Genesee CC | |
| Hollie Young | Starpoint | Colgate | |
| 1995 | Lucy Kelley | Lockport | |
| Amy King | Clymer | Daemen | |
| P.J. McTigue | Kenmore East | SUNY Geneseo | |
| Nicole Merlo | Olean | Coastal Carolina | |
| Geraldine White | Lockport | jr | |
| 1994 | Annquienette Burkes | Mount Mercy | Memphis |
| Lucy Kelley | Lockport | Jr | |
| Shannon Ferretti | Amherst | Villanova | |
| Tenika Swanson | Lackawanna | ||
| Harmonee Williams | Pine Valley | Yale | |
| 1993 | LaToya Crumpton | Hutch-Tech | Penn State |
| Gretchen Gegenfurtner | Sweet Home | ||
| Mary Grys | Holy Angels | Canisius | |
| Heather Rey | Lockport | ||
| Becky Wright | Newfane | Virginia Tech | |
| 1992 | Cami Cipriani | Holy Angels | Saint Rose |
| LaToya Crumpton | Hutch-Tech | Jr | |
| Katie DelSignore | Lewiston-Porter | ||
| Texlin Quinney | Sacred Heart | Seton Hall | |
| Carrie White | Lockport | ||
| 1991 | Dee Dee Mann | McKinley | |
| Texlin Quinney | Sacred Heart | Jr | |
| Anne Rudnicki | Holy Angels | Niagara | |
| Erica Rivers | Niagara Falls | ||
| Becky Wright | Newfane | Soph | |
| 1990 | Kathy Carroll | Salamanca | |
| Rachel Decker | Holy Angels | Canisius | |
| Beth Guiliani | Niagara-Wheatfield | ||
| Dee Dee Mann | McKinley | Jr | |
| Felice Mann | Burgard | Howard College | |
| 1989 | Kathy Carroll | Salamanca | Jr |
| Rachel Decker | Holy Angels | Jr | |
| Beth Guiliani | Niagara-Wheatfield | Jr | |
| Veronica Nowacki | Newfane | ||
| Lori Pasceri | Lockport | ||
| 1988 | Mary DelSignore | Niagara Falls | Buff State |
| Kris Hanson | Pioneer | ||