Past NYS Federation Finalist, Girls Basketball H-Public, C-Catholic, P-PSAL NYC, I-Independant
| 2008 | B | A | AA | |||||||
| Notre Dame C | Mary Louis Acad C | Murray-Bergtraum (P) | ||||||||
| 2007 | B | A | AA | |||||||
| 2006 | B | Bronx Aquinas | A | St Peters C | AA | Christ the King C | ||||
| 62-52 | 71-46 | 79-66 | ||||||||
| South Jefferson | Pittsford Sutherland (H) | Murray-Bergtraum (P) | ||||||||
| 2005 | B | John Glenn (H) | A | Holy Trinity (C) | AA | Murray-Bergtraum (P) | ||||
| 40-36 | ||||||||||
| Buffalo-Nichols (I) | Honeoye Falls-Lima-(H) | Christ the King (C) | ||||||||
| 2004 | no longer held | no longer held | B | Holy Trinity | A | Archbishop Malloy | Murray-Bergtraum (P) | |||
| 2003 | D | St Dominic(C) | C | Jamica- Arch Molloy C | B | Statan Is-St John Villa C | A | Murray-Bergtraum (P) | ||
| 70-43 | 51-47 | 61-39 | 55-53 | |||||||
| NYC Grand St (P) | Ovid So. Seneca (H) | New Hyde Park (H) | Christ the King (C) | |||||||
| 2002 | D | Mary Louis Acad (C) | C | Bishop Kearney (C) | B | Our Lady of Lourdes (H) | A | Murray-Bergtraum (P) | ||
| 57-31 | 53-45 | 70-54 | ||||||||
| Immaculate Heart-(H) | Voorheesville (H) | St Francis Prep (C) | Christ the King (C) | |||||||
| 2001 | D | Kellenberg C | C | St John Villa (C) | B | Our Lady of Lourdes (H) | A | Colonie (H) | ||
| 54-40 | 46-43 | 78-51 | 72-55 | |||||||
| Odessa-Montour (H) | Lansing (H) | St Francis Prep (C) | Murray-Bergtraum (P) | |||||||
| 2000 | D | Haldane (H) | C | Bronx-Mon. Scanlon (C) | B | Our Lady of Lourdes (H) | A | Christ the King (C) | ||
| 44-36 | 65-61 | 40-29 | 62-47 | |||||||
| Mt St Ursula © | Bloomfield (H) | St Francis Prep C | Murray-Bergtraum (P) | |||||||
| 1999 | D | Notre Dame Batavia (H) | C | Cardinal Spellman C | B | Our Lady of Lourdes (H) | A | Christ the King C | ||
| 49-45 | 58-48 | 48-42 | 63-51 | |||||||
| Our Lady of Mercy C | Bloomfield (H) | Bishop Kearney C | Shenendehowa (H) | |||||||
| 1998 | D | Riverside I | C | Bishop Kearney C | B | Oneonta H | A | Christ the King C | ||
| 62-35 | 56-52 | 60-40 | 70-62 | |||||||
| Bishop Loughlin C | Voorheesville H | St Dominic C | Corcoran H | |||||||
| 1997 | D | Buffalo-Nichols I | C | Burke Catholic (H) | B | Holy Angels C | A | Christ the King C | ||
| 69-65 | 49-38 | 53-45 | 82-54 | |||||||
| Pine Valley H | Bishop Kearney C | Oneonta (H) | August Martin (P) | |||||||
| 1996 | D | Haldane H | C | Westhill H | B | St Dominic C | A | Christ the King C | ||
| 49-39 | 61-34 | 57-45 | 65-44 | |||||||
| Hempstead-Sacred Ht C | Notre Dame C | John Jay H | Bishop Maginn H | |||||||
| 1995 | D | Mt St Ursula C | C | Our Lady of Lourdes H | B | St Francis Prep C | A | Christ the King C | ||
| 56-42 | 69-59 | 46-45 | 69-35 | |||||||
| Long Is Lutheran I | Mt Mercy C | Corning West H | Sachem H | |||||||
| 1994 | D | St Johnsville H | C | Our Lady of Lourdes H | B | Ursuline H |